Although she does look like she could win the love of Matty, eliminated contestant Simone Ormesher told WHO that she thinks Elise is being played.

“She’s come out of nowhere it was really late on in the show,” she said. “Like it was me and her, sat together getting nothing, and all of a sudden she’s there. She’s so lovely but I think she’s being played a little.”

This article originally appeared on WHO.