MarieClaire
  • News
  • Fashion
  • Beauty
  • Lifestyle
  • Career
  • Bridal
  • marie hair
  • Gifts
  • The Edit
  • Discount Codes
MarieClaire
  • News
  • Fashion
  • Beauty
  • Lifestyle
  • Career
  • Bridal
  • marie hair
  • Gifts
  • The Edit
  • Discount Codes
Subscribe
  1. Home
  2. News

This Horrific Australian Murder Case May Finally Receive More Answers, Courtesy Of A New Inquest

The 1973 case could hear new evidence in 2021. - by Lucy Cocoran
  • 15 Jun 2021
This Horrific Australian Murder Case May Finally Receive More Answers, Courtesy Of A New Inquest

The 1973 Whiskey Au Go Go Fire might not be a case you’re particularly familiar with, but it is one that has shaped the criminal history of Australia in a big way. The incident saw 15 people lose their lives in a tragic firebombing at a nightclub in Brisbane’s Fortitude Valley. Up until the Port Arthur massacre in 1996, this case was one of the worst mass murders in modern Australian history.

It was 2.10am when two 23-litre drums of diesel fuel were ignited in the building foyer. The drums were thrown through the open door and lit by torch, sending carbon monoxide up into the club’s main room on the first floor. Grease had been smeared over the stairs of the building’s rear fire escape, as had the door, making it incredibly difficult (if not impossible) to open. The fifteen people who lost their lives died of asphyxiation after not being able to open the door. There was estimated to be around 100 patrons, staff and entertainers in the club at the time. Many escaped by jumping through broken windows onto an awning, bracing for impact on a 15 feet drop to the ground.

go go whiskey fire
ABC News

John Andrew Stuart (then 33) and James Richard Finch (then 29) were found guilty of the fire bombing attack. The two underworld thugs protested their innocence profusely, claiming they had been convicted on false confessions. They pleaded not guilty, but were convicted for the murder of Jennifer Denise Davie (a drinks waitress at the club). The jury found the pair had lit the fire as part of an extortion-terror campaign aimed at Brisbane nightclub operators. They were sentenced to life in prison, but Stuart was found dead in his cell six years later after a six-day hunger strike. Finch battled for release and won in 1988 after serving 15 years, as part of his release conditions he was deported back to his birth country, England.

While it might sound like an open-and-shut case, a new inquest is investigating whether more people could have been involved. Avelina Tarrago, counsel assisting the coroner, says the investigation will hear evidence that a “considerable number of people other than Stuart and Finch were responsible for the fire.”

whiskey fire

One of the people in question is convicted murderer Vincent O’Dempsey. Sources say there is a significant collection of evidence mounting which ties him to the arson – one of them being his connection to his victims Barbara McCulkin and her two daughters (who allegedly knew too much about the fires). It is believed their murder may have been motivated by a desire to silence them, and prevent them from giving evidence against O’Dempsey.

O’Dempsey’s lawyer has made a request for disgraced former NSW Detective Roger Rogerson to give evidence. Rogerson was part of the original police investigation into the nightclub attack, and the inquiry heard he didn’t believe O’Dempsey was involved. Rogerson, however, is currently serving a life sentence for the murder of Jamie Gao, so how he will give evidence remains unclear.

Devastatingly, the victims’ families still do not feel they have closure, despite the passing of several decades. It is hoped that this new inquest will shed further light on the matter, bringing those involved to justice.

Speaking to 9News last month, Sonya Caroll, daughter of nightclub victim Desmae Selma Caroll, said:

"We want closure, we deserve closure, and so does everyone else who is involved in this. I need answers for my brothers, my mother; I just need answers."

The inquest continues today.

  • News
  • Crime
Lucy Cocoran
Lucy Cocoran
Lucy Cocoran is the lifestyle editor (digital) of marie claire and ELLE. When she’s not following the scent of pastries, she enjoys listening to true crime podcasts and smiling at dogs.

Subscribe to Marie Claire-+ save!

Subscribe to marie claire

Subscribe Now
Subscribe to Marie Claire

Subscribe to Marie Claire-+ save!

Subscribe to marie claire

Subscribe Now
Subscribe to Marie Claire

Recommended to you

MAFS' Aleks and Ivan exchange wedding vows
Watch 4:43

MAFS' Aleks and Ivan exchange wedding vows

{headline}

{headline}

Who Is Candy Montgomery? The Murderous Housewife At The Centre Of Jessica Biel's New Series

Who Is Candy Montgomery? The Murderous Housewife At The Centre Of Jessica Biel's New Series

Here's How The Infamous Claremont Serial Killer Was Finally Brought To Justice

Here's How The Infamous Claremont Serial Killer Was Finally Brought To Justice

Why Everyone Is Talking About Netflix's 'Girl In The Picture'

Why Everyone Is Talking About Netflix's 'Girl In The Picture'

Why Did Ted Bundy Not Kill His Girlfriend, Elizabeth Kloepfer?

Why Did Ted Bundy Not Kill His Girlfriend, Elizabeth Kloepfer?

{headline}

{headline}

Ghislaine Maxwell Has Been Sentenced To 20 Years For Sex Trafficking Crimes

Ghislaine Maxwell Has Been Sentenced To 20 Years For Sex Trafficking Crimes

Experts Dismiss The Popular Theory That Melissa Caddick Faked Her Own Death

Experts Dismiss The Popular Theory That Melissa Caddick Faked Her Own Death

Everything To Know About The Shocking Homicide Of Pro Cyclist, Anna Moriah Wilson

Everything To Know About The Shocking Homicide Of Pro Cyclist, Anna Moriah Wilson

{headline}

{headline}

The Showrunners Of ‘The Staircase’ On Toni Collette’s Extreme Resilience When Recreating *That* Fatal Scene

The Showrunners Of ‘The Staircase’ On Toni Collette’s Extreme Resilience When Recreating *That* Fatal Scene

'The Girl From Plainville's' Susie Pierce Is Likely Based On This Close Friend Of Michelle's

'The Girl From Plainville's' Susie Pierce Is Likely Based On This Close Friend Of Michelle's

The 'Underbelly' Portrayal Of Melissa Caddick Has Been Hit With Major Controversy

The 'Underbelly' Portrayal Of Melissa Caddick Has Been Hit With Major Controversy

The Harrowing (And Confusing) True Crime Story Behind Netflix's 'The Staircase'

The Harrowing (And Confusing) True Crime Story Behind Netflix's 'The Staircase'

What Happened To The 'Tinder Swindler' And His Victims After His Arrest?

What Happened To The 'Tinder Swindler' And His Victims After His Arrest?

Netflix's Latest Film 'Yara' Is Based On A Real Murder Which Rocked Italy

Netflix's Latest Film 'Yara' Is Based On A Real Murder Which Rocked Italy

The Best True Crime Podcasts Of 2021 That Promise To Terrify And Entertain You

The Best True Crime Podcasts Of 2021 That Promise To Terrify And Entertain You

MarieClaire
  • About Us
  • Discount Codes
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
MarieClaire Magazine Subscribe
  • About Us
  • Discount Codes
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

Brands

  • Beauty Crew
  • Home Beautiful
  • Elle
  • Who

Our Network

  • Better Homes and Gardens
  • BHG Shop
  • beautyheaven
  • New Idea food
  • New Idea
  • Girlfriend
  • That’s Life
  • Practical Parenting
  • All Recipes
  • Perth Now
  • The West Australian
  • 7Plus
  • 7mate
  • 7NEWS
  • 7Sport
  • Sunrise
  • Starts at 60
  • Hard to Find
© 2022 Are Media PTY LTD
All products are independently selected, tested or recommended by our team of experts.If you buy something, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Get more from Marie Claire

Magazine Subscription Offer

Subscribe to Marie Claire-+ save!

Shop This Offer
Subscribe to Marie Claire