First up in was Justin, spotted being consoled by his Mrs-to-be during a bike ride in the city, before the couple stopped into a café, and then Hailey too was spotted crying.
Cue the internet trying to make sense of the bizarre sighting, and the conspiracy there’s rolled in hard and fast.
But now we have to wonder no more, with Justin giving us an explanation.
Spotted leaving Hailey’s NYC apartment, the ‘Sorry’ singer was carrying a booked titled ‘The Meaning Of Marriage’ according to TMZ.
When a photographer asked him why he and Hailey were crying, Biebs pointed to the book and said, ‘this’.
"What is that?" the photographer asked. "Timothy Keller?"
To which Justin responded, "You got good days and you got bad days.”
"It's not real if it doesn't have any bad days."